Are data visualizations just smoke and mirrors?

The overarching premise of a briefing note is to provide a recommended action or response to an issue based on the background and analysis of the issue, and the identification of the advantages and disadvantages of the options for action that are identified.   While notes may be brief, especially at the Minister’s level, there is still the requirement that good policy is evidence based and evidence generally involves data.

Not every briefing note requires the use of visualization techniques.  Even for more complex issues, evidence may be legislative or precedence based and while the issue may be complex, it may not require the use of statistics to point to an optimized action to be recommended.  Where visualizations become important is when the data you are working with is extensive or complex.

Especially in cases where there may be more than one tenable option, the issue is new, or the recommended option is innovative or counter to current practice, the analyst should use all of his or her skills to assist the governing body to make an appropriate decision.  These skills include knowing your audience, presenting your information in a clear and concise manner and recognizing when a visual representation of statistics or other data makes your information easier or quicker to understand.

In the case of a Minister’s note, using a visualization to reduce a wall of words or a huge table of data into a more concise format is assistive.   Whether or not you use visualizations or decide to stick to a more neutral presentation, what makes it assistive and not manipulative is the reason you make that choice.  You don’t need a visualization to obfuscate an issue; if your intent is to unduly influence someone, it can be done just as well with neutral but misleading or incomplete presentation of facts so while a visualization may be given a different weight than a bullet point or table of data, understanding when and why it is appropriate to relay information visually goes a long way towards ethical public policy.

Leave a Reply