There are challenges inherent in every type of communication and public policy is no different. Public policy involves using evidence-based analysis to look at options, assess risks, and develop recommended actions based on the possible outcomes.
In the face of the current climate where the masses are bombarded with polarizing information in the guise of news or facts, evidence-based analysis is more important now than it has ever been. It won’t sway the blinkered, but it will help public servants make defensible decisions on public policy.
Background information can involve measurement of the past and when measuring the past, you can be precise. When you analyze and develop policy, you look at probabilities.
Take talking about the weather, for example. It’s easy to understand the factual past in that Regina received 0.2 mm in the last 24 hours but in looking at the probability of precipitation (POP) for the next 24 hours, that level of precision would not be appropriate. If people understood the calculation for the POP, they’d stop maligning the poor, misunderstood meteorologist. The POP is the percentage of time that weather conditions just like the time period being forecast would result in precipitation, so a 60% POP means that if you had 10 days with exactly the same atmospheric conditions, you could expect precipitation to fall over some portion of the forecast area in 6 of 10 similar days.
The use of probabilities is also essential in the assessment of the risk associated with any policy. Possible impact without an associated likelihood doesn’t show which risks to focus your mitigation strategies on.
But unless people (including you!) understand what you are trying to convey when you use probabilities, the use of probabilities is counterproductive. Probability statements based on industry specific calculations such as POP are commonly misunderstood as people don’t understand the calculations that they are based on and people likely don’t look on the percentage in the same way that a meteorologist does.
Reduce the risk that your audience will be unable to properly assess likelihood by providing a definition that explains your probability statement within your analysis. Policy doesn’t deal with the incontrovertible. Increase your POBU (probability of being understood) through definition of terms that are commonly misunderstood.