Perhaps the title of my blogpost is a bit of a spoiler alert to the outcome of the Health Employment Security Index (HESI) rankings but in case you can’t tell which country ranked number one on the HES index by the title I’ll spoil it fully now; it was the United States of America (USA).
In examination of the data indicators selected, it is fairly apparent why this isn’t really a ranking that tells anyone much but I’m sure there is at least one person south of the border that would consider this the unfakest news. Is it on Fox News yet?
To construct the index, I selected four indicators across three dimensions. My thoughts at the time were that the more secure a population is in having a minimum amount of education required to be employed, in being able to get a secure job, and living in a country that has significant spending on the healthcare system, the higher a country would score on the Health Employment Security Index.
Being employed in a job that isn’t exploitative and having healthcare available goes a long way to providing a sense of mental and physical health for me, perhaps it would do the same for others.
The indicators I chose were government health spending as a percentage of the country’s GDP, a composite indicator based on unemployment percentage and vulnerable employment percentage and finally, the percentage of the population over 25 that at has at least some secondary education. I figured that blending unemployment with vulnerable employment would provide a measure of not only being employed but being employed in with an adjustment of how likely the job was a ‘good’ job. Vulnerable employment includes self employed workers with no employees and people that work for family but are not at a level that would be considered a partner. They are less likely to have formal work arrangements, and are therefore more likely to lack decent working conditions. As unemployment is a negative aspect and the other two dimensions had (what I considered to be) positive indicators, I used the inverse of the unemployment data to have all positive indicators contributing to the HESI.
The health spending indicator I had chosen had no data for 2017 and in fact, it was somewhat difficult to find indicators that comprehensively included most, if not all of the countries in the Human Development Index (HDI). In order to not make this more complex than needed, I chose to stick with these indicators. While three of the four indicators used data from 2017 for the most part, the health spending data was from 2015. There were a few countries where I opted to use the most recent data in order to include them in the rankings.
Another issue was that for the dimensions using a single indicator, the country with the minimum score in the indicator had to be adjusted by 0.001 to allow for a geometric mean to be calculated for the index and I noted these by using red text in the data table.
The outcome was that the USA came out with the number one ranking. This made me look at my assumptions and the data chosen as I think I’d feel very unwell in an employment/health way if I was in the USA.
Perhaps the health spending in the USA is so high because it is some of the most expensive healthcare in the world. Perhaps countries have found a way to provide health care at a lower cost.
Looking at the two countries at the top of the HDI: Norway dropped from #1 on the HDI to #7 on the HESI, mainly due to mid-pack health spending relative to its GDP. Switzerland predictably remained neutral.
Canada? Canada rose from 12th place to 6th on the HESI due to a very high education score and a better than average employment score but was batting 500 on healthcare spending.
The country that gained the most in the rankings was Liberia where the ranking increased 107 spots! The country that dropped the most in the rankings was Brunei Darussalam which dropped 117 spots between rankings and both of these were affected most by the country’s healthcare spending or lack thereof so it is likely this dimension would be better represented by another indicator or at least by blending this indicator with another one.
While the USA spends a lot of money on the most expensive healthcare system in the world and you are unlikely to have to work for your dad who won’t pay you anywhere near where you should be paid as long as you get some secondary schooling, this may not be the strongest wellness index on earth. Sorry, DT.